9 Best Restaurants Open for Thanksgiving Dinner Fort Myers – 2024
Thanksgiving seems like the perfect time to celebrate a delicious meal in Fort Myers.
The place is known for its beautiful coastal areas and its vibrant local culture.
It has a variety of restaurants that provide a diverse range of cuisine options.
Therefore, dining here, next to historic sites and picturesque waterfronts, will definitely add to the experience.
If you’re looking for a delightful Thanksgiving meal in this place, then you will like our list.
Our list of some of the best Thanksgiving restaurants in Fort Myers is designed to give you a peek into various restaurants.
These restaurants come with their own beautiful view and tasty dining options.
Let’s check some of them out below.
The Best Thanksgiving Restaurants in Fort Myers This Year
Farmer’s Market Restaurant
Why is it a must visit?
Farmer’s Market restaurant is known for its down-to-earth and casual atmosphere. It’s an affordable restaurant that’s perfect for families.
The inviting and simple space has made it an easy-going restaurant in the city. The atmosphere is friendly and humble, which is perfect for grabbing a tasty Thanksgiving dinner.
The place focuses on Southern and American cuisine with traditional holiday dishes. It includes dishes that are made with a homemade touch. Therefore, if you are feeling homesick, then you will enjoy coming here. As one of the great restaurants, it features options like creamy mashed potatoes, roasted turkey, and sour stuffing. They also have cranberry sauce, green bean casserole, and other options. All of these dishes are loved by the local people here and are almost satisfying in every manner.
Location & Contact
- Website: https://www.farmersmarketrestaurant.com/
- Phone: 239-334-1687
- Address: 2736 Edison Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33916
Fancy’s Southern Cafe
Why is it a must visit?
Fancy’s Southern Cafe is another home-like restaurant if you’re looking to grab a last-minute meal. The prices here are pretty cheap, and the interior is warm and bustling with a lively vibe.
It’s one of the cool places to eat southern cuisine in Fort Myers, and it has friendly hospitality. It is as if you’re dining indoors since the place is so accommodating and welcoming.
Besides providing takeout options, the place focuses on southern comfort cuisine. Their Thanksgiving menu is exceptional, with options like collard greens, fried chicken, waffles, and various other Southern favorites. These flavorful dishes are made with rich flavors, tradition, and comfort. The menu and atmosphere make it one of the nicest restaurants in Fort Myers.
Location & Contact
- Website: http://www.fancyssoutherncafe.com/
- Phone: 239-561-2988
- Address: 8890 Salrose Ln #101, Fort Myers, FL 33912
Lighthouse Waterfront Restaurant
Why is it a must visit?
Lighthouse Waterfront restaurant is another neighborhood favorite restaurant with beautiful, serene views.
It’s one of the top-rated restaurants in the city and a relaxing spot with an approachable and upscale atmosphere.
The place provides a blend of new American cuisine and seafood offerings. It offers gourmet dishes with traditional options. These include seafood dishes like shrimp or fresh with traditional like turkey. They also have various gourmet side dishes like truffle mashed potatoes and roasted veggies. The waterfront view has made it a pretty romantic spot for dates.
Location & Contact
- Website: https://lighthousewaterfrontrestaurant.com/
- Phone: 239-489-0770
- Address: 14301 Port Comfort Rd, Fort Myers, FL 33908
Mel’s Diner
Why is it a must visit?
Mel’s Diner is well appreciated for its nostalgic vibe and its retro ambiance. It is one of the top-rated restaurants in Fort Myers, and it has a friendly and informal atmosphere.
If you’re planning to visit with your friends to enjoy a hearty Thanksgiving meal, then this place is perfect. It has classic elements that contribute to a welcoming and unique feeling.
The place is known for classic American Thanksgiving specials. These include traditional roasted turkey and essential sides like cranberry sauce. As a part of side options, they also have gravy and stuffing. The comforting and straightforward atmosphere of the restaurant, with a no-frills approach, has made it a favorite among locals.
Location & Contact
- Website: http://www.melsdiners.com/
- Phone: 239-275-7850
- Address: 4820 S Cleveland Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33907
Bahama Breeze
Why is it a must visit?
Bahama Breeze is known for its tropical and vibrant theme. It has a pretty relaxed and lively atmosphere.
If you’re wondering where to eat a festive Thanksgiving dinner in Fort Myers, then this is it. The place is a perfect blend between celebrating Thanksgiving and enjoying a festive atmosphere.
The menu features tasty Caribbean-inspired dishes. Options include a fusion of tropical and traditional flavors. Can expect dishes like jerk season turkey, creative side dishes, and island-style options. The energetic atmosphere and its unique menu have made it one of the most famous restaurants in Fort Myers, Florida.
Location & Contact
- Website: https://www.bahamabreeze.com/
- Phone: 239-454-9234
- Address: 14701 S Tamiami Trail, Fort Myers, FL 33912
University Grill
Why is it a must visit?
University Grill is a 5-star restaurant, unlike its name, and is known for its elegant and approachable atmosphere.
It’s a perfect option if you’re looking for a fine dining experience with an elegant atmosphere. The upscale decor of the restaurant helps elevate the entire experience of Thanksgiving.
The menu provides a mix of American cuisine with seafood and steak. The place features a spectacular menu with traditional turkey and pies. These are made with gourmet touches and tasty sides. They are truffle-infused stuffing and tasty roasted root veggies, making for incredible holiday side options.
Location & Contact
- Website: https://theugrill.net/
- Phone: 239-437-4377
- Address: 7790 Cypress Lake Dr, Fort Myers, FL 33907
Seconds Eatery
Why is it a must visit?
Seconds Eatery is known for its warm and inviting space with an emphasis on Southern hospitality. It’s a perfect local spot for those who are looking to come with their families for an inclusive and homey Thanksgiving.
The place is known for providing an affordable and comforting Thanksgiving.
This place focuses on home-like cuisine. So options include comforting and flavorful dishes like collard green, stuffed salmon, and macaroni cheese. They also have other staples that will make your day. Their generous portions have made it one of the most stand-out restaurants in the city.
Location & Contact
- Phone: 239-258-2304
- Address: 3204 Lincoln Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33916
Murder Mystery Dinner Train
Why is it a must visit?
Murder Mystery Dinner Train is known for its unique dining experience and is one of the cool places to eat Thanksgiving dinner in town.
The place is known for its interactive and immersive atmosphere, which has made it popular among youngsters. It makes for a fascinating holiday dinner with a lot of beautiful elements.
People enjoy their Thanksgiving menu, which includes various classic options. They also have a live mystery performance in a theatrical way. Options like their holiday specials and side dishes have it pretty famous.
Location & Contact
- Website: https://semgulf.com/
- Phone: 239-275-8487
- Address: 2805 Colonial Blvd #1012, Fort Myers, FL 33916
Farmer Joe’s
Why is it a must visit?
Farmer Joe’s is more like a market and less like a restaurant, but it is still worth mentioning on the list.
The place is known for its humble atmosphere, high-quality gradients, and ready-to-eat Thanksgiving meals. It is a practical and convenient space if you’re looking for last-minute meals.
It only provides takeout and delivery, and it does not feature dine-in services. But still, it is highly praised for its quality, like traditional turkey stuffing inside options. People who want to enjoy Thanksgiving without leaving their house and making dishes by themselves will appreciate ordering from this place.
Location & Contact
- Website: https://farmerjoes.com/
- Phone: 239-510-4385
- Address: 1401 SW Pine Island Rd, Cape Coral, FL 33991
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right restaurant can be a game changer for this Thanksgiving.
That’s why if you want to add a special touch to your Thanksgiving, you should look up these restaurants.
All the restaurants in our list, including some of the best Thanksgiving restaurants in Fort Myers, were suitable for your preference.
These provide a perfect backdrop for celebrating Thanksgiving in a festive manner.
Restaurants here range from family-friendly places to cozy and upscale diners.
If you want to make your Thanksgiving memorable, then you should check out this restaurant for delightful meals.
Wish you a joyous, happy Thanksgiving and bon appétit !
Jane Doe is a passionate travel writer with a special love for Thanksgiving traditions around the world. With over a decade of experience exploring different cultures, Jane brings a unique perspective to her stories, highlighting the diverse ways people celebrate gratitude. Her vivid descriptions and heartfelt narratives transport readers to picturesque locations and festive gatherings. When she’s not on the road, Jane enjoys cooking up Thanksgiving feasts for her family and sharing her travel tips on her popular blog.
