13 Best Restaurants Open for Thanksgiving Dinner Sarasota – 2024
As the holiday season approaches, the bustling city of Sarasota transforms into a haven for Thanksgiving festivities. With the scent of roasted turkey and spiced pumpkin pie traveling through the air, local restaurants are preparing to offer unforgettable dining experiences. This article will guide you through some of the finest restaurants in the area, highlighting their unique Thanksgiving offerings and inviting ambiences, ensuring a memorable celebration for all.
Savor a Luxurious Thanksgiving at Sarasota’s Most Renowned Dining Establishments
Kacey’s Seafood
Kacey’s Seafood transforms into a warm, inviting haven perfect for celebrating the season. The ambience is comfortable, with friendly staff greeting you with genuine smiles and setting the stage for a delightful dining experience. Cosy tables invite conversation while the scent of fresh seafood wafts through the air, promising a feast for the senses. The menu showcases a variety of tempting dishes, ideal for a festive gathering.
Enjoy the rich, velvety lobster bisque that warms the soul or savor the shrimp trio—coconut, fried, and wasabi—each bite bursting with flavour. For the main course, the grouper seared in garlic butter stands out, impressing even the most discerning palates. Whether you’re feasting with family or friends, Kacey’s Seafood offers the perfect backdrop for a memorable Thanksgiving celebration, where every dish is crafted to delight and inspire.
Location & Contact
- Website: http://kaceysseafood.com/
- Phone: (941) 378-3644
- Address: 4904 Fruitville Rd Sarasota, FL 34232
Element: steak. Seafood. Pasta
This Thanksgiving, treat yourself to an unforgettable dining experience at Element, where elegance and warmth combine for a truly special celebration. The ambience is sophisticated yet inviting, with refined decor that creates a calming atmosphere that is perfect for gathering with loved ones. The attention to detail is evident from the moment you step in, with the friendly staff going above and beyond to ensure your evening is smooth and enjoyable.
The menu is a feast in itself, offering a delightful variety of options. From perfectly cooked steaks that melt in your mouth to seafood dishes like shrimp linguine, every bite is bursting with flavour. The sides, especially the rich cream corn, are the perfect complement to the main courses, leaving you wanting more. Pair your meal with a handcrafted cocktail or a selection from their expansive wine and whiskey list for an added touch of indulgence.
Location & Contact
- Website: http://elementsrq.com/
- Phone: (941) 724-8585
- Address: 1413 Main St Sarasota, FL 34236
Palm Avenue Deli
Palm Avenue Deli offers a wonderful dining experience, blending authentic deli cuisine with a welcoming atmosphere. The interior decor combines the charm of a New York deli with modern touches like subway tiles, copper lighting, and beautifully curved accents throughout the space. It provides a cosy yet vibrant setting for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. The menu has classic deli staples, including corned beef sandwiches, matzo ball soup, latkes, and a variety of bagels.
Each dish is crafted with attention to detail, offering generous portions full of flavor. The corned beef is especially praised for its tenderness and rich taste, while items like the Reuben and smoked Rachel sandwiches add a modern twist to traditional offerings. Whether enjoying a casual meal inside or dining al fresco, guests are treated to friendly service that enhances the overall experience. Palm Avenue Deli has quickly become a local favourite, celebrated for its flavorful dishes .
Location & Contact
- Website: http://palmavenuedeli.com/
- Phone: (941) 263-3742
- Address: 1297 North Palm Ave Sarasota, FL 34236
Mattison’s Forty-One
Mattison’s Forty-One is the ideal spot for a memorable Thanksgiving celebration, blending warmth, elegance, and incredible food. As soon as you enter, you’re welcomed by a cozy atmosphere, with live piano music and walls adorned with artistic tributes to musical legends. The ambience perfectly balances sophistication with comfort, making it an inviting space for family gatherings. On Thanksgiving, expect a feast to delight every palate.
Their Thanksgiving menu offers a variety of hearty dishes, from their tender beef brisket poutine to marinated strip steak that melts in your mouth. Seafood lovers will relish the jumbo shrimp or perfectly grilled salmon, while vegetarian options like fresh veggie fettuccine add a delightful twist. Add to this the impeccable service—attentive and friendly staff who make sure you feel right at home—and you have the recipe for an unforgettable holiday. Celebrate Thanksgiving at Mattison’s Forty-One, where every detail adds to the joy of the occasion.
Location & Contact
- Website: http://mattisons.com/
- Phone: (941) 921-3400
- Address: 7275 S Tamiami Trl Sarasota, FL 34231
Marina Jack
Marina Jack is a premier waterfront dining destination located in Sarasota, known for its stunning views of Sarasota Bay and vibrant atmosphere. Guests can enjoy a variety of dining options, including indoor and outdoor seating, where they can savour delicious meals while taking in the beautiful surroundings. The restaurant offers a diverse menu featuring fresh Seafood, gourmet dishes, and speciality cocktails, making it a perfect spot for casual lunches or romantic dinners.
In addition to its exceptional dining experience, Marina Jack provides opportunities for sunset dinner cruises, allowing guests to enjoy the serene beauty of the bay while enjoying a delightful meal. The venue often hosts live music events, enhancing the atmosphere and creating a lively experience for diners. Whether celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a day out, Marina Jack caters to a variety of preferences, making it an ideal destination for locals and tourists alike.
Location & Contact
- Website: http://marinajacks.com/
- Phone: (941) 365-4232
- Address: 2 Marina Plz Sarasota, FL 34236
Seasons 52
As the festive season approaches, Seasons 52 stands out as an inviting destination for Thanksgiving. The ambience has a casual sophistication, perfect for gathering with family. Guests are welcomed into a warm, beautifully designed space that harmonizes elegance with comfort, creating the ideal backdrop for shared memories. The culinary offerings are a feast for the senses. Diners loved the seasonal menu, which has dishes like cedar plank salmon and tender filet mignon, each crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients.
The flatbreads and roasted artichokes are standout starters that set the stage for a memorable meal. With a dedicated staff ensuring every need is met, this restaurant guarantees a delightful dining experience that celebrates both the flavors of the season and the joy of togetherness. This Thanksgiving, make Seasons 52 your go-to spot to savor the spirit of gratitude and delicious food.
Location & Contact
- Website: http://seasons52.com/
- Phone: (941) 702-9652
- Address: 170 University Town Center Dr Ste 103 Sarasota, FL 34243
Ophelia’s on the Bay
Ophelia’s on the Bay offers a breathtaking waterfront dining experience that combines exquisite food with stunning views. Guests love the intimate atmosphere, perfect for special occasions like anniversaries and birthdays. The menu has highlights such as crab cakes, lobster bisque, and the popular eggplant crepes, praised for their flavour and presentation. Service is consistently noted as exceptional, with attentive staff providing excellent recommendations on food and wine pairings.
Many diners enjoy the beautiful outdoor seating, which enhances the overall ambience, especially during sunset. Desserts, particularly the Reverse Black Forest Cheesecake, also receive high praise. With a reputation for outstanding dining and unforgettable experiences, Ophelia’s on the Bay is a top choice for those looking to celebrate in Sarasota.
Location & Contact
- Website: https://opheliasonthebay.net/
- Phone: (941) 349-2212
- Address: 9105 Midnight Pass Rd Sarasota, FL 34242
Marina Jack
Located on the picturesque Sarasota Bay, Marina Jack offers a breathtaking waterfront setting that enhances the Thanksgiving experience. As you arrive, the gentle sounds of the marina and the sight of moored yachts create an inviting atmosphere perfect for family gatherings. The restaurant’s elegant interior has large windows that provide stunning views, while outdoor seating allows diners to enjoy the cool autumn breezes under twinkling lights. The Thanksgiving menu at Marina Jack showcases a delightful blend of traditional and innovative dishes.
Guests can savor juicy roasted turkey with homemade cranberry sauce and rich stuffing alongside fresh seafood options highlighting local flavors. The dedicated staff is known for their warm, attentive service, ensuring a memorable dining experience. With its enchanting ambience, exceptional cuisine, and commitment to hospitality, Marina Jack is an ideal destination for celebrating Thanksgiving, creating cherished memories that will last long after the meal.
Location & Contact
- Website: http://marinajacks.com/
- Phone: (941) 365-4232
- Address: 2 Marina Plz Sarasota, FL 34236
Siegfried’s Restaurant
Located in the heart of Sarasota, Siegfried’s Restaurant and German Biergarten offers an authentic taste of Germany, making it a delightful choice for Thanksgiving gatherings. The cosy ambience, a reminder of traditional German beer gardens, invites guests to enjoy hearty meals around long wooden tables, where laughter and conversation flow freely. On Thanksgiving, the menu has beloved German dishes such as Wiener schnitzel, served with savory mushroom gravy, and freshly made potato dumplings, ensuring a memorable feast.
Visitors love the giant pretzels and delightful currywurst, which pair perfectly with a selection of German beers. With attentive service from the friendly staff, many of whom share the owners’ German roots, diners feel at home in this charming eatery. Whether celebrating with family or friends, Siegfried’s combines festive ambience, delicious cuisine, and a touch of tradition, creating a Thanksgiving experience that feels both warm and authentic.
Location & Contact
- Website: http://siegfrieds-restaurant.com/
- Phone: (941) 330-9330
- Address: 1869 Fruitville Rd Sarasota, FL 34236
Wink Wink Food & Drink
Located in The Modern Hotel in Sarasota’s Rosemary District, Wink Wink Food and Drink offers a blend of contemporary cuisine and a vibrant atmosphere. The restaurant’s decor has artistic elements and digital artwork that create an engaging space, perfect for dining both indoors and outdoors. The menu showcases diverse dishes, including the highly praised Brussels sprout appetizer and the stunning Cobb salad.
A standout is the Pipi Popo Loco Moco, which has wagyu beef, rice, shiitake mushrooms, and a sunny-side-up egg. Desserts, such as the deconstructed cheesecake, are perfect for sharing. Wink Wink also has an impressive cocktail menu, highlighted by craft creations like espresso martinis and Old Fashioneds, all served by knowledgeable bartenders. Wink Wink is ideal for any occasion, making it a must-visit destination in Sarasota.
Location & Contact
- Website: http://winkwinkmodernlounge.com/
- Phone: (941) 906-1290
- Address: 1290 Boulevard Of The Arts Sarasota, FL 34236
Fork & Hen
Fork & Hen is a charming restaurant located in Sarasota, known for its delicious Southern-inspired cuisine. The cosy atmosphere includes limited indoor seating and outdoor options, creating a warm, inviting space for diners. The menu has standout dishes like the Blue Plate Southern Fried Chicken, Chicken and Waffles, and unique Crab Rangoon Drop Biscuits. Guests love the generous portions and creative flavour combinations. Desserts, especially the cheesecake made with local mango, receive high praise.
The attentive and friendly staff enhances the dining experience, making it ideal for families and friends looking to enjoy flavorful, comfort food in a relaxed setting. Whether for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, Fork & Hen is a great spot to savor hearty meals in Sarasota.
Location & Contact
- Phone: (941) 960-1212
- Address: 2801 N Tamiami Trl Sarasota, FL 34234
Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant- Sarasota
Cooper’s Hawk is a refined dining spot in Sarasota, renowned for its exceptional food and wine pairing experience. The restaurant has an elegant ambience that creates a welcoming atmosphere for guests. The menu has a variety of delicious dishes, such as the red wine-braised short rib and crispy Brussels sprouts, which are consistently praised by diners. The wine-tasting experience is a highlight, with knowledgeable staff guiding patrons through their selections.
Guests appreciate the variety and quality of the wines available, often mentioning the attentive service. Special occasions are well accommodated, making it a popular choice for celebrations. With its focus on quality cuisine and an extensive wine list, Cooper’s Hawk provides an enjoyable dining experience for food and wine lovers alike, ensuring that every visit is memorable.
Location & Contact
- Website: http://chwinery.com/
- Phone: (941) 263-8100
- Address: 3130 Fruitville Commons Blvd Sarasota, FL 34240
Cafe Gabbiano
Located in the heart of Siesta Key, Cafe Gabbiano offers an amazing escape for Thanksgiving, blending the charm of a cozy Italian cafe with an inviting atmosphere. As you step inside, you’re greeted by the warm glow of softly lit interiors, decorated by rustic decor that reflects a true Italian aesthetic. The ambiance has comfort, making it an ideal setting for festive gatherings with family and friends.
The menu is a celebration of authentic Italian cuisine, where each dish is crafted with care and passion. Diners love the soft shell crab special and the unparalleled lasagna, both renowned for their freshness and flavor. Guests appreciate the attentive staff, who ensure a memorable dining experience. As the Thanksgiving festivities unfold, enjoy generous portions and exceptional wines, making Cafe Gabbiano a perfect destination to create cherished holiday memories.
Location & Contact
- Website: http://cafegabbiano.com/
- Phone: (941) 867-4146
- Address: 5104 Ocean Blvd Sarasota, FL 34242
Conclusion
As you plan your Thanksgiving celebration in Sarasota, consider these diverse restaurant options that promise to enhance your holiday experience. With a mix of traditional and innovative dishes, these eateries allow you to enjoy the holiday without the hassle of cooking. This Thanksgiving, let the local culinary scene improve your festivities, allowing you to focus on gratitude and connection.
Frequently asked questions
Yes, Many Thanksgiving restaurants in Sarasota, such as Mattison’s Forty-One and Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant, provide takeout options for those who prefer to celebrate at home.
The average price for a Thanksgiving dinner at restaurants in Sarasota ranges from $30 to $75 per person, depending on the restaurant and the the menu.
Yes, many Thanksgiving restaurants in Sarasota, like Element and Wink Wink Food & Drink, accommodate dietary restrictions.
Sarasota has several family-friendly Thanksgiving restaurants, such as Fork & Hen, which has a welcoming atmosphere and a special kids’ menu for young diners.
Yes, Many Thanksgiving restaurants in Sarasota, like Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant and Element, provide wine or cocktail pairings to enhance your meal.
Yes, Many Thanksgiving restaurants in Sarasota, such as Mattison’s Forty-One and Marina Jack, offer private dining options for larger groups.
Yes, some Thanksgiving restaurants in Sarasota, including Marina Jack and Ophelia’s on the Bay, offer outdoor seating options.
It’s best to book your Thanksgiving meal at least a few weeks in advance, as popular restaurants in Sarasota like Element and Kacey’s Seafood tend to fill up quickly for the holiday season.
Jane Doe is a passionate travel writer with a special love for Thanksgiving traditions around the world. With over a decade of experience exploring different cultures, Jane brings a unique perspective to her stories, highlighting the diverse ways people celebrate gratitude. Her vivid descriptions and heartfelt narratives transport readers to picturesque locations and festive gatherings. When she’s not on the road, Jane enjoys cooking up Thanksgiving feasts for her family and sharing her travel tips on her popular blog.
