13 Best Restaurants Open For Thanksgiving Dinner Key West – 2024

13 Best Restaurants Open for Thanksgiving Dinner key west – 2024

ByJane Doe

Key West, with its sunny skies and laid-back vibe, offers a Thanksgiving experience unlike any other. This tropical island city is where holiday traditions meet a coastal twist, making it the perfect place to celebrate Thanksgiving in a unique way. 

If you’re wondering where to eat, Key West has some of the nicest spots to enjoy a holiday meal, ranging from cozy eateries to fine dining establishments. The local restaurants take the holiday seriously, offering special menus that combine the best of traditional Thanksgiving fare with fresh, local flavors. 

Whether you’re searching for fine dining or just looking for “food near me,” Key West has a spot that’s ready to serve up a memorable feast. So come and explore—there’s something here for everyone, and Thanksgiving in Key West is an experience you won’t want to miss.

Best Restaurants for Thanksgiving Celebration in Key West This Year

 Here’s a roundup of the best restaurants in Key West to make your Thanksgiving extra special:

Blue Heaven

At Blue Heaven, Thanksgiving takes on a delightful Key West twist. This charming spot, known for its relaxed island vibes, transforms into a cozy haven for the holiday. Picture yourself in a colorful, artsy space where the atmosphere is as warm and inviting as the food. The relaxed, free-spirited environment sets the stage for a Thanksgiving feast that’s anything but ordinary. The menu boasts a seafood lover’s dream with dishes that capture the essence of the island.

Blue Heaven
Source

While the mashed potatoes might be on the minimalist side, the key lime pie and lobster Benedict steal the show, offering a unique spin on traditional flavors. If you’re looking to enjoy a Thanksgiving meal with a touch of Key West charm, Blue Heaven is your go-to destination. Come for the festive flair, and stay for the unforgettable island-inspired dishes.

Location & Contact

Louie’s Backyard

At Louie’s Backyard, Thanksgiving transforms into a relaxed, seaside feast with a touch of elegance. Situated right on the ocean, this Key West gem offers spectacular views that set the perfect backdrop for your holiday meal. The menu is a celebration of fresh, local flavors. You can enjoy expertly crafted dishes such as juicy crab cakes, tender steaks, and delicious shrimp and grits. Each plate is a wonderful fusion of traditional holiday fare and tropical flair, with a unique and satisfying dining experience.

Louie's Backyard
Source

Whether you’re strolling on the breezy deck with stunning sunset views or enjoying a cozy indoor setting, Louie’s Backyard provides an unforgettable Thanksgiving experience. The friendly service, combined with the beautiful surroundings and delectable food, makes this the perfect place to enjoy a festive holiday meal in a relaxed, oceanfront setting.

Location & Contact

Hot Tin Roof

Hot Tin Roof in Key West is a great place for Thanksgiving. It sits right on the water, giving you a beautiful view of the sunset while you eat. The atmosphere is relaxed and stylish, perfect for a special holiday meal. The food is both tasty and unique. You can try dishes like lobster bisque, tuna tacos, and shrimp mac and cheese, all prepared with care and flavor.

Hot Tin Roof
Source

Each meal feels like a treat, making it a fun way to celebrate. With both indoor and outdoor seating options, you can enjoy your meal in a cozy or breezy setting. Hot Tin Roof offers a fantastic combination of great food, lovely views, and a friendly vibe, making it a top pick for Thanksgiving in Key West.

Location & Contact

Sarabeth’s Key West

For a Thanksgiving treat that’s off the beaten path, Sarabeth’s is the perfect choice. Picture this: a snug, intimate space where you can escape the hustle and bustle. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it feel like your second home. The menu is packed with comforting surprises. Start with shrimp and grits, followed by French toast that’s both sweet and savory. The caramel espresso martini is a standout with its unique rimmed concoction.

Sarabeth's Key West
Source

For a special touch, try the crispy bacon with maple dipping sauce and save room for the famous bread pudding. Whether you choose to dine inside in a cool, quaint space or enjoy a seat by the window, this café offers a memorable Thanksgiving experience with delicious food and a welcoming ambiance.

Location & Contact

Kaya Island Eats

At Kaya Island Eats, Thanksgiving takes on a tropical twist with its special dishes that showcase the best of island flavors. With a name like Kaya Island Eats, you know the vibes are relaxed, and the food is all about island flavors. This year, they’re offering a feast of juicy jerk turkey and Caribbean-style stuffing, guaranteed to bring a unique and delicious spin to your holiday table. As you step into the restaurant, you’ll feel the island vibes instantly.

Kaya Island Eats
Source

The relaxed and vibrant atmosphere, complete with colorful decor and a lively ambiance, makes it a perfect spot for a casual, festive meal. Their menu features standout dishes like crispy jerk wings, fresh mahi-mahi tacos, and creamy key lime pie. Each plate bursts with bold flavors and creative twists that keep diners coming back for more. Visit Kaya Island Eats for a Thanksgiving experience that’s both festive and fun.

Location & Contact

Grand Cafe Key West

At Grand Cafe Key West, Thanksgiving turns into a tasty celebration. Their special holiday menu features perfectly roasted turkey with savory gravy and a delicious pumpkin cheesecake, making your holiday meal truly memorable. The restaurant has a warm and inviting feel. Set in a lovely restored home, it offers a peaceful porch for a quiet meal. Inside, the elegant yet cozy décor creates a welcoming atmosphere for any occasion.

Grand Cafe Key West
Source

The menu is packed with delicious choices, from fresh mahi-mahi and conch fritters to mouthwatering bruschetta. Every dish is made with care, showing the chef’s commitment to great flavors.Whether you’re enjoying yourself after a relaxing Thanksgiving dinner or a special night out, Grand Cafe Key West offers fantastic food and a charming setting for a dining experience you’ll love.

Location & Contact

Pepe’s Cafe & Steakhouse

At Pepe’s Cafe & Steakhouse, Thanksgiving is a real treat with their festive menu. They’re serving up a juicy turkey with all the classic sides and a creamy pumpkin pie that’s perfect for the season. Pepe’s offers a cozy, old-school vibe that makes you feel right at home. With its charming decor and friendly atmosphere, it’s the kind of place where you can relax and enjoy a great meal.

Pepe's Cafe & Steakhouse
Source

The menu is full of favorites like fresh oysters, savory steak, and their famous key lime pie. Whether you’re starting your day with a hearty breakfast or coming in for a delicious dinner, Pepe’s has something for everyone. If you’re looking for a warm, welcoming spot to celebrate Thanksgiving or just enjoy a fantastic meal, Pepe’s Cafe & Steakhouse is the place to be.

Location & Contact

Breakfast Club Too

At The Breakfast Club, Thanksgiving brunch is a feast to remember, along with their special menu. Highlights include a savory turkey feast and a delectable pumpkin spice French toast, perfect for celebrating the holiday in style. The atmosphere at The Breakfast Club Too is casual and fun, with a vibrant, ocean-themed decor that sets a cheerful mood.

Breakfast Club Too
Source

On the menu, you’ll find everything from mouthwatering lobster Benedict to the giant pancake charcuterie board. Their extensive selection ensures there’s something delicious for everyone. For a memorable Thanksgiving brunch or a tasty breakfast any day, The Breakfast Club Too offers great food, friendly service, and a lively setting that will make your meal special.

Location & Contact

Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar

This Thanksgiving, Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar is the place to be. Dive into a holiday feast with juicy roasted turkey and a rich pumpkin cheesecake that will make your celebration extra special. The atmosphere here is relaxed and welcoming, with gorgeous marina views and a chic, cozy interior. It’s a great spot for a leisurely holiday meal.

Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar
Source

The menu boasts tasty options like shrimp linguine and perfectly cooked chicken, each dish a testament to the chef’s skill. Whether you’re enjoying a breakfast with bottomless mimosas or a delicious dinner, Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar delivers a delightful experience. For a Thanksgiving meal that’s both delicious and scenic, Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar stands out as an excellent choice.

Location & Contact

The Lobster Shack Key West

If you’re in Key West this Thanksgiving and craving something special, The Lobster Shack is where to feast. This cozy little spot is like finding buried treasure—except the gold here is delicious lobster rolls! The menu may be small, but that’s because they’ve perfected every bite. These lobster rolls are so stuffed with fresh, tender lobster, you’ll wonder how they managed to fit it all in there.The place has a laid-back vibe with just a few tables, but that’s part of its charm.

The Lobster Shack Key West
Source

Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or sitting down to soak in the Key West scene, you’re in for a treat. The staff is as friendly as they come, serving up tasty food with a side of good humor. Pair your roll with a refreshing limeade, and you’ve got yourself a Thanksgiving meal that’s far from ordinary. It’s the kind of spot that makes you want to come back, again and again!

Location & Contact

Tavern N Town

Experience Thanksgiving at Tavern N Town, where the holiday meets elegance with a touch of local flair. Located in Key West, this spot combines a cozy, dimly lit atmosphere with a touch of sophistication—perfect for a holiday meal that’s both relaxed and refined. Imagine enjoying your Thanksgiving feast while a live band provides the soundtrack to your festive cheer. The menu features a mouthwatering variety of options, from prime rib that’s so tender it practically melts to shrimp linguine that promises to delight.

Tavern N Town
Source

For dessert, don’t miss the molten cake—it’s so good, even the staff can’t resist peeking in to watch it being made. Whether you’re here for the bottomless mimosas at brunch or a full Thanksgiving dinner, Tavern N Town offers a memorable dining experience that’s sure to make your holiday special. So, if you’re in Key West, come for the food and stay for the fun!

Location & Contact

Cafe Sole

If you’re in Key West for Thanksgiving, don’t miss out on Cafe Sole—it’s like the holiday feast you didn’t know you were missing! Picture this: a cozy restaurant where the atmosphere feels like a warm, welcoming hug. You’ll be greeted with a menu that’s all about local seafood and tasty French-Caribbean dishes. The Hogfish Snapper Sole is a crowd-pleaser, and it’s so delicious you might forget to save room for dessert.

Cafe Sole
Source

But you’ll want to make space for the Key Lime Pie, which is basically tropical sunshine on a plate. The whole dining experience here is like a holiday in itself: friendly service, pretty food, and a vibe that makes you want to stay forever. So, for a Thanksgiving that mixes great food with a lot of charm, Cafe Sole is your spot. Come for the amazing eats, stay for the cozy atmosphere, and leave with a big smile—and maybe a food coma.

Location & Contact

Latitudes

For a Thanksgiving meal that’s more “wow” than “whoa, I overdid it,” Latitudes on Sunset Key is the place to be. Picture this: you hop on a charming boat ride that takes you away to a tropical island paradise. The ferry ride alone feels like the start of a mini-vacation! Once you arrive, you’ll be greeted with breathtaking ocean views and a menu that’s just as delightful. The sunset views are nothing short of magical—perfect for setting the scene for a festive feast.

Latitudes
Source

The Snapper with crispy kale is a standout, and if you’re a fan of Key Lime Pie, prepare for a slice that might just make you a convert. Latitudes know how to do Thanksgiving right with a relaxed vibe, stunning scenery, and food that feels like a hug from the inside out. So, if you’re in Key West , this place should be on your radar. 

Location & Contact

Conclusion

In summary, Key West has some great spots for a special Thanksgiving meal. Café Sole offers a cozy vibe with tasty seafood, while Latitudes on Sunset Key provides stunning sunset views and a fancy island feel. Whether you want a laid-back dinner or a beautiful setting, these places will make your Thanksgiving memorable. Just remember to book early and enjoy a wonderful holiday with great food and a festive atmosphere in Key West!

Frequently asked questions

Do Key West restaurants offer special Thanksgiving menus?

Yes, Many dining spots provide special Thanksgiving menus or dishes with traditional and local ingredients.

Is it necessary to make a reservation for Thanksgiving dinner in Key West?

Yes, making a reservation in advance is recommended to secure a spot, as popular places can get fully booked.

Are there vegetarian or vegan Thanksgiving options available in Key West restaurants?

Yes, Some restaurants offer vegetarian or vegan Thanksgiving dishes. It’s best to check the menu or inquire in advance.

Are there waterfront dining options for Thanksgiving in Key West?

Yes, Key West has several restaurants with beautiful waterfront views that offer Thanksgiving meals.

What is the typical cost for a Thanksgiving meal in Key West?

The cost varies, generally ranging from $30 to $100 per person depending on the place and menu.

Do any restaurants offer Thanksgiving takeout or dinner delivery in Key West?

Yes,Some places may offer Thanksgiving takeout or delivery. It’s advisable to check with individual restaurants.

What unique Thanksgiving dishes might guests find in Key West restaurants?

Guests will find local seafood or Caribbean-inspired twists on traditional Thanksgiving fare.

Do restaurants in Key West accommodate food allergies or dietary restrictions for Thanksgiving?

Yes,Most places are willing to accommodate dietary restrictions if informed in advance.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *